Oct 9, 201301:00 PMPoint of View

The METROPOLIS Blog

Another Architecture Classic Gone

Another Architecture Classic Gone

Courtesy Landmark Illinois

This article, by Rory Stott, originally appeared on ArchDaily as “AD Classics: Prentice Women’s Hospital / Bertrand Goldberg

Hospital buildings, with their high standards of hygiene and efficiency, are a restrictive brief for architects, who all too often end up designing uninspiring corridors of patient rooms constructed from a limited palette of materials. However, this was not the case in Bertrand Goldberg‘s 1975 Prentice Women’s Hospital. The hospital is the best example of a series of Goldberg-designed medical facilities, which all adhere to a similar form: a tower containing rooms for patient care, placed atop a rectilinear plinth containing the hospital’s other functions.

Courtesy C. William Brubaker © via Flickr user UIC Digital Collections

Goldberg’s approach was to let the interior requirements of the building define the exterior form, which gave rise to the peculiar plinth-and-tower form of his hospitals. The lower floors contained surgical suites, research laboratories, dining facilities and maintenance areas. Because future developments in medical technology may require spaces to be changed dramatically, Goldberg chose the form of a rectilinear plinth, which provides the greatest possible flexibility. On the other hand, since the role of a hospital (accommodating and caring for patients) was unlikely to change, Goldberg felt the building’s tower need not be flexible. Here, Goldberg was inspired by anthropologists such as Edward T Hall, who were developing theories of human interaction in different spatial orientations.

 

 

 

Courtesy Landmark Illinois

The ‘four leaf clover’ plan of this tower splits each floor into four tiny communities, fostering greater social ties between the neighboring occupants. The radial arrangement creates a large number of crisscrossing routes around each floor, meaning there is more chance for incidental social encounters than in a typical hospital with rooms arranged along a corridor. It also places all patients roughly equidistant from the centrally-located nurses’ station, allowing for efficient care.

Courtesy Landmark Illinois

With the exterior form determined by this interior layout, and requiring external load bearing walls, most structural solutions of the time would have required columns supporting the structure. However, by taking the radical approach of employing software developed by the aeronautics industry (some 20 years before Frank Gehry made this tactic famous), it was possible to cantilever these structural walls from the central core of the building. This is a structural solution which, according to Goldberg’s son Geoffrey Goldberg, is not found anywhere else in the world.

 

 

 

Courtesy © Flickr user the justified sinner

With its focus on human relationships and building community, its striking concrete form, and its use of the most modern structural solution available at the time, the Prentice Women’s Hospital (as well as Bertrand Goldberg’s work as a whole) brings together a number of streams of architecture from the early 70s, touching on Brutalism, the humanism of architects such as Aldo Van Eyck, and the Metabolist movement dominated by Japanese architects such as Kenzo Tange and Fumihiko Maki.

Courtesy © Flickr user seanbirm

Sadly, the importance of this building and its singular combination of architectural influences was not enough to guarantee its place in the ever-changing streets of Chicago. Despite efforts of dozens of architects, and even a last-ditch proposal from Jeanne Gang and The New York Times’ Michael Kimmelman, the owners, Northwestern University, demolished the building in the summer of 2013, claiming it could not meet the needs for a cutting-edge biomedical research facility they have planned for the site.

 

Architects: Bertrand Goldberg

Location: 333 East Superior Street, Chicago, IL 60611, USA

Architect In Charge: Bertrand Goldberg

Year: 1975

Photographs: Courtesy of Landmark Illinois, C. William Brubaker via Flickr user UIC Digital Collections, Flickr user seanbirm, Flickr user the justified sinner

This past June, the news came from The Chicago Architecture blog, that the "demolition of the former Prentice Womens’ Hospital... is underway.  Crews have removed the skywalk connecting the bulbous Bertrand Goldberg-designed building to Northwestern’s Lurie Medical Research Center next door...

The removal left a portion of Prentice’s west side bashed in.  It’s also been marked up with spray paint to guide demolition teams as they continue turning this tower into a vacant lot.

"When we visited, the air was filled with the sounds of shattering glass.  One of the workers apparently had the task of bashing in all of the windows one by one.  A destructive childhood dream come true, perhaps; but sad to see happening to this once noble building." Does anyone in Chicago have the latest on Prentice? Is it dead or just mortally wounded?--Ed

Add your comment:

About This Blog

Examining contemporary life through design, architecture, interior design, product design, graphic design, crafts, planning, and preservation.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Digital Edition

{$publication.name} - Digital Edition

METROPOLIS is now available on your tablet or mobile devices 

Learn more »