Above: Birds collected outside the World Trade Center and World
Financial Center in Manhattan last fall. Each year more than
1,000 birds are injured or killed upon colliding with these
buildings. Photography by Jimmy Cohrssen.
Offsite: Visit the New York City
Audubon Society to find out about preservation proposals
for New York's birds. For further monitoring of the World
Trade Center birds, call (212) 691-7483.
Ned Boyajian is one New Yorker who doesn't look
forward to spring. Boyajian, you see, is one of several Audubon Society
volunteers who pick up dead and injured birds that have crashed into the
glass at the World Trade Center and World Financial Center, in Lower Manhattan.
Every morning is another bird bloodbath. At just those two complexes,
a thousand birds are killed or wounded every year, according to Audubon
estimates. On Columbus Day weekend last year, 52 dead birds greeted Boyajian
and his team. On another fall day Boyajian picked up 33 dead and injured
birds--some were still crashing into the building as he was cataloging
the carnage. "It's awful to watch," he says.
It's also extremely common. In Chicago a lakefront
glass building called McCormick Place has killed as many as 200 birds
in one day. And a communication tower in rural Kansas killed an estimated
10,000 Lapland longspurs on a foggy night two years ago--an avian
Jonestown massacre.
A billion birds die every year as a result of our
need to see outside, according to Muhlenberg College professor Daniel
Klem Jr., the author of several studies on bird-glass collision. According
to Klem, lights atop tall towers disorient birds, who had no problem navigating
by the stars before we invented electricity. Instead of continuing on
their nocturnal migratory route, the birds circle skyscrapers--sometimes
for hours--like moths around a flame. Some of the fatigued fowl simply
die of exhaustion. Others find a resting place wherever they can--often
in vest-pocket gardens near tall buildings. When the still-tired birds
resume their migration, they often slam into the glass, either because
they see only a reflection of the sky or because they are trying to make
their way to all that lush vegetation in the lobby. "When a bird
is flying, its vision is projected at long distances," Klem says.
"Our suspicion is--and we're not birds, so we can only guess--that
the bird is flying too fast to even be aware of its own image in the glass."
The solution to the problem involves more than just installing a 20-story
owl on top of the World Trade Center. (Although who wouldn't love
to see that?) The Port Authority, which runs the complex, has lowered
the death toll by covering part of One World Trade Center with common
netting--but many birds still die around the rest of the building.
Klem's research shows that outdoor planters need
to be less than 12 feet from any glass so that departing birds will not
reach top speed. He also wants to take a page from welfare reform and
end glass as we know it. He's formulated several varieties that look
normal from inside a building but are unattractive from the outside. Such
surfaces scare birds, but they also scare architects. Klem presented his
findings to the presumably sympathetic Architects, Designers, Planners
for Social Responsibility, but the group has done nothing. The Empire
State Building recently promised to shut off its fabled floodlights whenever
a member of the Audubon Society reports that birds are circling, but this
promise will probably go the way of "No New Taxes" when the
reports start pouring in.
Klem understands well the futility of the battle he's
been waging for 25 years. "My level of alarm seems to be shared by
few," he says. But that only prompts him to make a bolder statement:
at a recent ornithological symposium, Klem didn't illustrate his
lecture with slides--he just brought in some birds that had been killed
around the building that morning.