Above:The renovation of Newtown Creek (New
York City's largest sewage-treatment plant, top) will
include a nature walkway (bottom) and pools for kids to play
in (second from bottom).
Since 1967 the neighborhoods along the industry-scarred
channel separating Greenpoint, Brooklyn, from Long Island
City, Queens, have reluctantly hosted the Newtown Creek
Water Pollution Control Plant, New York City's largest
sewage-treatment plant. Recently the Department of
Environmental Protection (DEP) began an estimated $2 billion
revamp of the plant that should eliminate the "eau de
New York" that now perfumes the area--but most
residents would still rather see it torn down than fixed up.
Though the city is unwilling to consider moving the plant
elsewhere, it is offering a small consolation: in exchange
for continuing to host the city's 310-million-gallon-a-day
bladder, the natives of Greenpoint are receiving several
public art projects that promise to turn the site of the old
municipal central crapper into an unlikely monument to
sewage treatment.
Greenpoint is teeming with civic organizations, many of
which have conflicting visions for the area's development,
but it's reasonably certain that none of them ever included
an homage to wastewater treatment. Ten years ago, however,
when the DEP began planning the long overdue upgrade
required to bring the plant into accord with the Clean Water
and Clear Air Acts, the department learned that a
decades-old initiative required one-half of one percent of
the project's cost to be allocated to public art at the site.
Enter George Trakas, waterfront designer, who won the
Percent for Art commission and charmed the Newtown Creek
Monitoring Committee--the group that oversees the plant's
renovation--with his plan to open up the adjacent land to
the public and convert the plant into a didactic tool, if
not exactly a source of neighborhood pride. "He's got
so much enthusiasm; he's like a force of nature. It's really
infectious," says Bob Gormley, former community liaison
officer for the committee.
Indeed Trakas, who has navigated local waterways in a
homemade kayak and built parks through-out the United States
and Europe, is somewhat of a waterfront park evangelist.
"Greenpoint is desperately in need of assistance to
access some public waterfront," Trakas says. "I've
seen the changes happening on the Newtown Creek since the
early seventies with the demise of a lot of the polluting
industry there. Since the water quality has upgraded
tremendously and the wildlife has come back, I thought it
would be neat to make a waterside park on the edge of a
treatment plant." The Waterfront Nature Walkway,
stretching alongside the plant, will grant landlocked
residents their first public access to the surrounding water.
On the other side of the plant--where the egg-shaped domes
of its new disinfection facilities, designed by the Polshek
Partnership, abut defunct factories--Percent for Art
commissioned installation artist Vito Acconci to create
another olive branch for nearby residents. Acconci's Edge
of the Plant/Edge of the Neighborhood installation, a
ten-block stretch of chain-link fence with a playful tribute
to the municipal water system, appropriately features
squirting and pooling water. Meant to integrate the plant
with the neighborhood, it also serves as an entry to a new
visitors' center with educational exhibits on the
titillating process of sewage treatment.
Once the community became aware of the renovation, a deeper
appreciation for the history of sewage treatment emerged in
some quarters. One group is seeking to honor the plant's
ambivalent legacy by attempting to landmark the original
1967 sludge tank (to be decommissioned in 2003), which they
hope to turn into a community center, with the upper level
to be converted into a swimming pool.
It may be impossible to avoid the unpleasant juxtapositions
that arise from the scarcity of water resources in highly
populated areas. Sewage-treatment plants are unwelcome
additions to any neighborhood, but at least the thoughtfully
renovated Newtown Creek facility will give proper respect to
a public service that helps bring New Yorkers such modern
luxuries as a pot to piss in.