The Cuban response to this, in what has been said and what has been done
to Plaza Vieja, reveals how planners there see their task. Rigol has described
the schemes that emerged from the MAK symposium, including Moss's, as "amazingly
sophisticated." But she considers them "out of any possibility
to be currently applied to the Cuban context. Can something very attractive,
but without identity or relation with the country's essence, then emerge
as a new image of Cuban heritage?"
The answer would seem to be no. Plaza Vieja is a principal locus of preservation
work now. The parking garage was removed and the original grade restored.
The entire plaza has been reserved for pedestrians. At its center is a new
fountain that copies one from the eighteenth century. Slowly the buildings
at the periphery--mostly palatial town houses that had been subdivided into
apartments--are being renovated. In this process their original facades
are restored, ground-floor spaces are given over to public functions
such as galleries, and the floors above are reconfigured as modest
apartments; so far these are providing homes for some 50 neighborhood families.
The renewed Plaza Vieja will also include a cinema, school, and hotel.
But Cuban designers are not interested only in a strict historicist approach.
The hotel slated for restoration on Plaza Vieja, the 1906 Palacio Cueto,
is a sinuous Catalonian-style Art Nouveau confection. Plans call for an
addition that will reprise but simplify its lines and include a diaphanous
drape fluttering over a mural. When asked about a design direction
for infill construction on the hundreds of Havana plots where buildings
have collapsed, Rigol suggests that there's no reason new buildings shouldn't
be utterly fresh, drawing on the Cuban talent for Modernism and complementing
without duplicating the scale and styles of surrounding structures. She
points to several new examples of what is possible, like Roberto Gottardi's
renovation of a nineteenth-century building, in a joint venture with an
Italian investor, for the restaurant A Prado y Neptuno. It has a Modernist
interior furnished with Mackintosh-inspired chairs and a mural depicting,
among others, Frank Lloyd Wright, Carlo Scarpa, and Philippe Starck. In
a recent project by the Havana architects José Antonio Choy and Julia
León in Miramar--the city's classiest twentieth-century suburb, whose
villas now house embassies and foreign corporate offices--a 1957 bank
building was wrapped in a swooping Deconstructivist addition of glass and
steel. "The original classic Modern, sober facade [is] more evident
than it was before," Rigol has written, "intelligently showing
two different but matching stages of the building's life."
Havana's planners are drawing on the enthusiasm of foreign designers to
realize some of these projects. They invited Howard Ben Tré--a Providence,
Rhode Island, glass sculptor who recently turned to designing public plazas--to
produce a plan for Calle Aramburu, a teeming residential street in the dense
nineteenth-century Centro Habana district. Ben Tré describes his
charge principally as "to alter the way automobiles work in the streetscape."
He designed a scheme of slightly raised crosswalks that would discourage
non-local traffic and make the occasional presence of cars immediately
obvious. "The project will give physical support to a spontaneous pattern
in that area where neighbors live in the streets--probably because of overcrowding
inside their dwellings, but also as typical extroverts," Coyula says.
"We picked Aramburu because there is a neighborhood transformation
workshop, which provides a good link with the local residents--something
we feel is determinate if any project like this looks for success."
Ben Tré finds Cuban planners very well informed but handicapped
by the lack of resources: "I'm saying, 'We've got to replace these
telephone poles with trees.' But how are they going to do that? They're
not going to bury the power lines--it's expensive. So now we're talking
about hanging them off the building; Cubans are pretty resourceful.
"Havana is at an incredible moment in terms of what the city is going
to look like," he adds. "Developers from Europe come in who want
to build forty stories high, and they say, 'You want milk for your children?
Let us do it.' Fortunately they have only a few of those hideous new hotels
that come in containers--so far." The prospect of normalized relations
with the United States, and the destabilizing flood of dollars that
could follow, is sobering. But on this Duany strikes a calming note. "The
bureaucracy there is very sensitized and sophisticated," he says. "They
know what they have. Bureaucracies don't change. Who's going to replace
them?" Duany sees Havana as a prototype for the twenty-first century.
"All the cities I've been working in have as their vision what Havana
already has: streets that are walkable, mixed use, compactness. Cuba is
so far behind in the provision of cars that it would bankrupt the country
to become a car society. And in a way, they haven't crumbed themselves up
with outmoded infrastructure. So it's perfectly poised to leap ahead."
Jonathan Lerner writes on travel and design for Hemispheres, InStyle,
and Travel & Leisure. His novel Caught in a Still Place
is available in print-on-demand at www.penpowerpublishing.com.