The facility includes a new building, tracks and platforms, foundations
for the elevated station, state-of-the-art signaling, and a dramatic overhead
canopy that will stretch across the open-air platforms. Despite the ambitious
design, the project's biggest challenge was figuring out a way to do
the work. "Originally the job was going to take eight years,"
says Mike Kyriacou, design manager on the project with the New York City
Transit Authority. But he and his staff figured out a way to do it
in 42 months, although it means shutting some lines down for years at a
time. "We had to go to the community and say, 'We know you'll have
to suffer for a while,'" Kyriacou says. The present station is a wreck
of crumbling concrete and rusted metal--a sad testimony to the low priority
given to maintenance of public infrastructure. "The condition of the
existing facility is so dilapidated," he says. "It looks like
a place that no one has ever touched."
The most visually striking component of the station will be winglike glass-and-steel
canopies equipped with solar panels capable of generating enough electricity
to heat and cool the building. These will stretch across four platforms
and be visible from a considerable distance. The solar system will produce
the most electricity--150 kilowatts--on a hot summer day, precisely when
air conditioners around the city are draining the power system of Con Ed.
Below the canopy and platforms will be a three-story, 34,000-square-foot
building that will replace the existing one-story station. This will include
not only space for about 300 daily transit workers but also a new police
precinct house. The landmark-worthy mosaic facade of the old station will
be removed, cleaned, and rebuilt.
Andrew Berger, an architect at di Domenico + Partners in New York who designed
the new three-story building, says he believes the new station is "all
part of a bigger strategy, which is that if you build it, they will come.
It's a real opportunity to not only knit together an improved transit facility
and police station, but hopefully leave a positive statement about future
development opportunities out in Coney Island."
The renovation of the Coney Island--Stillwell Avenue stop should spur
development the same way a new highway creates more shopping malls and subdivisions.
The renovation will not expand capacity--but appearances are important.
In a few years visitors and residents of Coney Island will enter the new
building, lined with stores inside and out, then walk or roll up gently
sloping ramps to wait for a train under a futuristic glass canopy.
In addition to the subway, there are other city-funded projects under construction.
Mermaid Commons--developed by the New York City Department of Housing Preservation
and Development through a public-private partnership--is a series of in-fill
buildings along 13 blocks of Mermaid Avenue. The project includes an entire
block of three-story row houses, incorporating retail below and apartments
above, each selling for $274,000. The plan is to sell these to middle-income
families who will live on one fioor, run a retail store, and rent out
one apartment to another family.
Standing on the Coney Island boardwalk at sunset, you see an amazing parade
of passersby: a Hasid in a black hat and long coat, a snake handler, a Hispanic
woman with her ice-cream-smeared children, a white-haired man in a shirt
and tie speaking Russian to his grown blue-jeaned son. In a park off to
one side of the boardwalk, a group of Latino and black men play handball.
Coney Island has always been a melting pot. The novelist Joseph Heller,
in his memoir Now and Then: From Coney Island to Here, wrote of the
poor but thriving community of Jews, Italians, and other ethnic groups in
the 1930s. With a new ballpark and a renovated subway station and beachfront,
more people will come to Coney Island and blend into the soup.
However, many people are skeptical that better days are ahead. Calling it
"a cliché of seedy decay," David Barstow of the New
York Times recently wrote of how "the old-timers and tourists and
politicians cling like rust to the distant fantasy that Coney Island will
be what it once was, as if the great cultural and demographic tides that
built and then laid waste to the place were merely boardwalk phantasms."
But Barstow failed to mention the renovated subway line. If the MTA added
better express service to Manhattan, the island could be a half hour from
Wall Street. And as an oceanfront amusement park, Coney Island is still
not bad. Sitting in a rocking car on top of the Wonder Wheel, you can see
the ballpark and the elevated subway line that glides between the housing
towers nearby. From this vantage point, the train looks like another amusement-park
ride--perhaps one to try after the roller coaster. I suspect that in coming
years more people will try that ride, and visit Coney Island.
Alex Marshall is the author of How Cities Work: Suburbs, Sprawl, and
the Roads Not Taken.