Lewis Center for Environmental Studies, Oberlin College
Oberlin, Ohio, 2000
Based on the idea that students learn as much from buildings
as they do from course content, McDonough created an
innovative "fecund" design that includes a
solar-power system (top) that will be capable of generating
more energy than the building uses, a gardenlike
"living machine" wastewater treatment facility
(above, right), wetlands for storm-water management, and a
landscaped habitat for living things.
The offices of McDonough's design firm occupy the first and
second fioors of a converted redbrick vegetable warehouse in Charlottesville,
Virginia. Coal trains rumble constantly beneath the window of his spartan
second-fioor office, shuttling coal mined from West Virginia mountaintops
to power plants in Richmond, Virginia. McDonough moved the firm here
from New York in 1994, when he was named dean of the architecture school
at the University of Virginia. It employs 40 designers and has won almost
every imaginable architecture and environmental award. Yet McDonough has
also been recognized for his contributions to commerce. He's the first architect
to win the Business Week/Architectural Record Award two years in a row:
in 1997 for the Herman Miller factory in Holland, Michigan; and in 1998
for the Gap campus in San Bruno, California.
"Imagine that," McDonough says, opening an image of the 295,000-square-foot
glass-and-steel facility he designed for Herman Miller on his computer monitor.
"A green building that wins the highest business award for providing
value to a company." Completed in 1995, the essentially transparent
furniture factory includes a curved greenhouse-like corridor that joins
the lower office section with the higher manufacturing area. Light
monitors on the factory roof channel abundant streams of sunlight onto the
factory fioor throughout the day. Artificial wetlands planted
with native species around the facility retain and purify storm-water runoff.
"This building increased productivity at that factory by 24 percent.
At their volume, that increase is worth $60 million a year to Herman Miller.
The building cost $15 million. Ask any CEO if he'd accept a 400 percent
return on an investment. This isn't rocket science, you know. I used to
tell designers that we have no choice but to be humble. It took us five
thousand years just to put wheels on our luggage."
Nike European Headquarters
Hilversum, The Netherlands, 1999
The main building on the European campus (top) features
ground-source heat pumps that use the Earth's temperature to
control the building's climate, windows oriented and glazed
to admit maximum daylight and fresh air (as seen in the
commons lobby, bottom left), and a system for collecting
storm water for reuse as gray water.
For the Gap McDonough created a native-habitat roof--an undulating grassy
structure that echoes both the biology and the topography of the surrounding
San Bruno Hills. The grass roof catches and filters storm water as
well as provides thermal and acoustic insulation. Curved roof baffies
direct daylight onto interior spaces filled with plants. Raised fioors
and a system of fans and louvers provide for nighttime cooling; body heat
and machines provide much of its daytime heating. Along with the firm's
second consecutive Business Week award, the Gap project also took
first place in an energy-efficiency competition for new office
buildings conducted by Pacific Gas & Electric.
"We beat a building designed to have the minimal amount of sunlight
and the minimal amount of fresh air allowed by code," McDonough says,
his words acquiring speed and seeming to acquire mass as they rifie
off his tongue. "They were doing minimum, minimum, minimum. We aimed
for maximum, maximum, maximum. They were trying to be efficient. They
were efficient, and they used more energy. We don't want to be efficient--we
want to be effective. Look at a cherry tree. Look at all the blossoms. Is
a cherry tree efficient? No, it's effective. Imagine a building like
a tree. I'm going to give them a nontoxic environment that costs less to
run. I'm going to give them people that are happy to come to work. I want
to create life support for people who work, instead of work-support systems
for people who don't have a life."
In 1991 McDonough, noted green architect, received an invitation printed
on a disposable diaper for the opening of the New York offices of the
Environmental Protection Encouragement Agency. The EPEA was created by Braungart.
As an activist Braungart had paddled rubber boats to waste sites on the
Rhine, climbed chimneys at Swiss chemical factories, and been kicked and
punched by security personnel and factory workers. In 1986 he was involved
in a Greenpeace protest action on the factory roof of the Swiss chemical
company Ciba Geigy. On Christmas Day the executive officer asked Braungart
and his colleagues to climb down, offering them soup and fiowers--and
giving them his word that they could return if they so chose. The group
declined the offer. But when Braungart climbed down a few days later he
began a dialogue with the official, which led to a series of meetings
with Ciba CEO Alex Krauer. Through these discussions Braungart realized
that pure protest, although useful, was at best a partial solution. As an
environmentalist--and especially as a chemist--Braungart saw that it was
his duty not only to call attention to damage produced by industry but also
to propose solutions and alternatives that were ecologically acceptable
as well as economically viable. He subsequently created the EPEA.
901 Cherry, Offices for Gap Inc.
San Bruno, California, 1997
Phase I of this project is designed around the concept that
people would rather spend their time outside. Whether in the
offices (bottom left), conference rooms, dining facilities (bottom right),
or health club, people are never more than 30 feet from a
source of sunlight. The building has an insulating roof
(top), covered with native grasses and wildflowers, that
mirrors the lines of the landscape (below). It is 30 percent
more efficient than California law requires.
McDonough was one of the first guests to arrive at the EPEA's New York
reception. He and Braungart connected instantly and spent the entire evening
locked in dialogue on the roof garden, breaking only at brief intervals
when visiting German dignitaries or UN personnel interrupted them to be
introduced to Braungart. The following day Braungart showed up at McDonough's
offices and launched into a lecture about a second industrial revolution
in which all waste would be food, and biological nutrients would be returned
to the soil and industrial nutrients returned to industry. The energy problem
will be resolved, he told McDonough. We will have unlimited energy. We have
solar income. Stop thinking about energy and start thinking about detoxifying
our matter, which is limited.
"He kept telling me, 'You--you are the one, the architect--the one
who can transmit this message,'" McDonough recalls. "I told him
that he was the one to do it, but he wouldn't listen. Then he started talking
about Einstein as a poet, about the destruction of genetic material. I couldn't
follow him--I was too slow. So he asked me for a pencil and started drawing
on the walls of our conference room. And he kept going, going--like this
mad scientist--and we spent the entire afternoon drawing on the walls."
The writing on the wall did not foretell the end of nature, nor of the industrial
world as we know it. Instead Braungart's scribbled diagrams and words sparked
a collaboration with McDonough that would extend the architect's activity
into the realms of chemistry, commerce, and heavy industry. The pair's first
joint venture was the Hannover Principles, a series of guidelines for sustainable
development that McDonough and Braungart began drafting in 1991 for the
2000 World's Fair. In 1995 they established an official partnership,
McDonough Braungart Design Chemistry (MBDC), with offices in Charlottesville
and Berlin. The company consults with manufacturers across the industrial
spectrum. In place of fiagellating manufacturers with Judeo-Christian
guilt, McDonough and Braungart exhort industry to meditate on a future of
transcendent materialism--a brave new world of substances and machines whose
souls can be infinitely recycled.