Meet the Beetles
At its new theme park, Volkswagen puts on a branding show.
By Phil Patton
Photographed by Joachim Schumacher
|
|
Click
on any image to access the original plate.
|
|
In 1937 Ferdinand Porsche, father of the Volkswagen Beetle, traveled
to Detroit to study Henry Ford's vast River Rouge factory, hire
men, and buy machines to build an equivalent
plant for Adolf Hitler. In 1997 Otto Ferdinand Wachs, a top Volkswagen
executive, visited Las Vegas and Disney World to analyze two current
American specialties: theme parks and branding. The result of Porsche's
trip was the mile-long factory in Wolfsburg that built the Beetle.
The result of Wachs's trip opened on June 1: Autostadt ("Autocity").
Part Niketown, part Legoland, Auto-stadt resembles a miniature world's
fair, with gardens and water parks, an auto museum, a Ritz-Carlton
hotel, and pavilions devoted to seven of the nine brands under the
Volkswagen corporate umbrella. The 62-acre theme park, located adjacent
to the Wolfsburg plant, opened in connection with Expo 2000 in nearby
Hannover, but it will continue after the fair ends. Some 1.2 million
people are expected to visit each year. Tickets cost 24 DM (about
$12).
"It's a way to show the soul and spirit of the company," says Wachs,
Autostadt's exuberant
director and former head of VW public relations. "We want it to
serve as the company's platform for service and communication."
Autostadt suggests the degree to which automakers have taken on
the manners of show business. Today they don't just want to sell
cars, they want to bond with their customers. As Michael J. Wolf,
author of The Entertainment Economy, proclaims: "There's no business
without show business." Toyota has built an amusement park in Japan,
Saturn welcomes buyers to its Tennessee factory, and both Ford and
Chrysler have small museums near Detroit. But no car company has
undertaken as ambitious an effort as Volkswagen to polish its brand
image.
The high point of the trip to Autostadt for many visitors will be
the delivery of their new vehicles, ordered at local dealers but
stored in one of two glass and steel towers, each 20 stories high
and packed with 400 cars. Visually the towers are the centerpiece,
echoing the smokestacks of the factory's power station. About a
thousand visitors a day are expected to watch as mechanical arms
move up, grab a car, then lower it to the base of the tower. Vehicles
are fed through an underground tunnel to the customer center and
waiting buyers. The whole process resembles a gigantic vending machine.
(There's even room for four more towers-a future visual pun on a
six-cylinder car engine.)
This
contraption is just one of the elements that could make it easy
for brand-savvy Americans
to laugh at VW's efforts at showmanship. "To watch Germans do marketing,"
one commentator says, "is like watching elephants dance: even if
done clumsily it is fascinating to watch." But Volkswagen's U.S.
division is a marketing success story. Beginning in 1995 the "Drivers
Wanted" campaign created by Arnold Communications generated buzz
for the brand even before the arrival in 1998 of the New Beetle,
designed by J Mays and Freeman Thomas at the company's California
studio. But what VW did there is inspiring them to attempt the same
thing globally--and they should not be underestimated. No one
50 years ago thought the Germans could outdo the Americans in manufacturing,
but the facility that Porsche modeled on River Rouge became the
biggest car plant in the world. "Larger than Monaco,"
the tour guides like to say.
The
idea for Autostadt arose in 1995, when Volkswagen was asked to participate
in the
Hannover
World's Fair. "It was an opportunity to show our face to the world,"
says Robert Buechelhofer, head of sales and marketing for VW. But
for all the showbiz, "this is a place about selling without selling,"
says Gunter Henn, the chief architect of Autostadt, who directed
a 260-person team during its construction. His Munich-based firm,
Henn Architekten Ingenieure, specializes in buildings with unique
technical demands for high-tech and other industrial clients.
Americans like to think of themselves as the most car-obsessed people
on the planet, but Germans easily rival them. "The car is like a
member of the family," Wachs says. It's a tradition in Germany to
pick up cars at the factory, fresh off the assembly line. Sixty
percent of Porsches sold there are delivered to buyers where they
are built, in Stuttgart. Mercedes buyers take direct delivery of
some 200,000 vehicles at three "customer centers" in Germany. (In
the 1960s, when the dollar was all-powerful, American buyers of
Beetles would come to Wolfsburg to pick up their cars and, with
the money saved, enjoy a two-week trip through Europe.)
Although
they can come by car or boat, most visitors are expected to arrive
by rail, after an hour's
ride from Berlin or Hannover on the high-speed train. From the station
they cross a sweeping footbridge that cuts diagonally across the
Mittelland Canal, once used for coal and steel deliveries. They
enter the KonzernForum--a boxy welcome center with a glassed-in
piazza containing Cafes at one end, and interactive computer terminals
and 360-degree film projections at the other. A display called Gyroballs
allows visitors to take the place of crash dummies, strapping themselves
into a vehicle that rolls down an inclined track into a barrier.
Children can clamber through a 40-foot-high glass engine while their
parents take a virtual-reality trip down the Pacific Coast Highway.
The
nearby museum is made up of two joined buildings. The Zeithaus ("House
of Time") is the most interesting piece of architecture at Autostadt.
One half is a rectangular, five-story glass bookshelf, or "rack"
as Henn describes it, holding 80 vintage cars--not just VWs,
but Cadillacs and Mercedes as well--placed in nooks like models
in a vitrine. It's faced by a softly curved aluminum structure housing
interpretive exhibits. The two structures are joined in the middle
by bridges that represent an architectural dialogue between the
two halves of the brain.
Outside stand the pavilions, which Henn calls "embassies" and Buchelhofer,
the marketing man, "temples." Each brand is represented symbolically
by architecture.
The Volkswagen pavilion is a cube, with a sphere visible through
a glass wall; the simple geometric shapes evoke VW's timeless virtues:
quality, safety, value. The Audi building is shaped in the form
of interlocking circles, echoing the rings of its logo. The Bentley
pavilion, a Ray Hole-Furneaux Stewart collaboration, is built into
a hillside--almost completely underground--and covered in
the same granite as the nearby Ritz Carlton Hotel to suggest a shared
quality of luxury. Inside, the focus is a huge 16-cylinder Bentley
crankshaft. Skoda is centered on a dome with glass walls that fan
out in a vaguely cubist way. Henn says the Seat building (designed
by Alfredo Arribas), with extravagantly curved walls, reflects a
Spanish "rambla festival."
After Lamborghini became part of the VW empire two years ago, it
was also assigned a pavilion. An executive of another brand in the
VW group recalled how managers at Lamborghini were called to a meeting
and asked to define the "core values" of their brand. The Italians
showed impatience with the whole process. After much hesitation
and head-scratching, one blurted out, "Sex. Is sex."
What
they
got
for their pavilion is a dark cube expressing what the architects
describe as "pure emotion" and "impetuous power." Visitors follow
a twisting passage through the building as distant music segues
into the amplified heartbeat of a bull--the totem of the car--then
escalates into the roar of a powerful 12-cylinder engine that makes
the whole cube shake. They finally arrive in a room where a Diablo
sports car hanging on the wall glows an unearthly red, its engine
in full cry.
The ultimate stop for most visitors at Autostadt will be the customer
center, where they will pick up cars after having toured the plant
next door. Watching the vehicles emerge from the underground tunnel
is retail theater--a grander, more heroic version of the translucent
tubes at Niketown, through which new Air Jordans go shooting. Indeed
Autostadt in many ways seems an expanded, more serious variation
of that. "Romancing the brand" was the phrase Nike executives loved
to use in the early 1990s. "The idea behind Niketown," says Gordon
Thompson, who directed its design, was "to make the retail exchange
of money for goods more exciting." Thompson was inspired originally
by the great 1939 New York World's Fair. The lukewarm response generated
by the Hannover event, of which Autostadt is an adjunct, suggests
the degree to which theme parks and retailers have coopted the
magic of world's fairs.
Today corporate theater requires a mix of history
and brand honing. Niketown was about deploying the subbrands of
the mother-corporation in miniature environments,
from Air Jordan to All Conditions Gear, Tiger Woods golf equipment
to Mia Hamm soccer shoes. At Autostadt, pavilions play the same
role that rooms do in Niketown. But the latter is a wholly more
playful place. Thompson calls the shoe-tube delivery system "a totally
Spacely Sprocket product." Volkswagen seems to have seriously decided
to be playful, rationally decided to be emotional. That Autostadt
builds on the company's American success is suggested by its logo:
three joined arcs blurred by apparent motion, a variation on the
New Beetle emblem. The New Beetle changed VW's image and led to
the company's revival. But the car's enthusiastic reception came
as something of a shock to VW's German executives, helping to set
in motion the ideas behind Autostadt.
Volkswagen's
CEO, Ferdinand Piëch, distinguished the New Beetle as an "emotional"
model different from the company's other "rational" models, such
as the Golf. The original Beetle was a triumph of rationalized mass
production. The New Beetle represented a feat of design, style,
and marketing; it helped convince VW executives that as cars approach
each other in quality and manufacturing costs, design and marketing
will make the difference. It's an American lesson.
But theatrics like Autostadt do not come naturally in Wolfsburg.
Americans, after all, dreamed up the New Beetle in a California
studio; Wachs looked outside the company for talent to design Autostadt.
For restaurant design, he turned to New York-based Tony Chi and
Associates, and Jordan Mozer and Associates, in Chicago. The Lagune
restaurant and coffee shop by Tony Chi (Zen Palate, Harley Davidson
Cafe) serves cuisines from regions where the company has factories.
The metaphor of a car expanded to the scale of a restaurant lies
behind Cylinder, Jordan Mozer's diner-theme eatery, where the front
wall of the kitchen suggests an instrument panel and the chef is
the driver. Andrée Putman designed the interiors of the Ritz-Carlton,
whose curving shape fronts the old factory. She has used brick to
mirror the original factory buildings next door, which she compares
admiringly to "a woman unaware of her own natural beauty."
Wachs also hired Jack Rouse, who in the 1960s came to Wolfsburg
to pick up a Beetle (something Americans cannot yet do at Autostadt).
Rouse, whose Cincinnati-based firm has designed exhibits and rides
for Universal Studios, Six Flags, Legoland, and Kellogg's Cereal
City USA, handled many of the interiors and exhibitions for Autostadt.
"Volkswagen very much wanted to be perceived as an open, service-oriented
company," Rouse says. "Now they know it's not enough just to tout
their technology."
Although
Wachs insists that Autostadt "looks forward--it's not a monument,"
it is difficult not to see it as an implicit celebration of the
company's recent revival. Since Piëch took over as CEO in 1993,
VW has gone from an annual loss of $1 billion to a $2 billion profit
in 1999 by increasing quality and efficiency. Piëch, who had previously
turned around Audi, put Wolfsburg's workers on a four day workweek
and revived Seat, its Spanish arm, and Skoda, the Czech division.
He also built the VW group into an empire of star brands, buying
bankrupt Bugatti, which hadn't produced cars in 60 years; Lamborghini;
and Bentley, his apparent favorite. (He commutes from his home in
Braunschweig each day in a blue Bentley.)
Piëch is regarded as a brilliant engineer--he created the engine
for the legendary Porsche 911--but an impatient, even cruel
manager. His grandfather was Ferdinand Porsche; his father, Anton
Piëch, managed the VW plant during World War II and was imprisoned
for two years afterward along with Porsche. Ferdinand Piëch's presence
is a reminder that Autostadt carries risks: for VW to delve into
symbolism and history is to tread on very uncertain ground. Like
Piëch and Porsche, Autostadt is not a new name here. Wolfsburg,
Volkswagen's company town, began life in 1938 as Hitler's planned
Kraft durch Freude Stadt ("Strength through Joy City"), a model
Nazi-worker town planned by Peter Koller, a disciple of Albert Speer.
But the locals simply referred to it as the car city, Autostadt.
Wolfsburg was a name borrowed from a nearby castle by British occupation
authorities in 1945.
The ground on which the new Autostadt stands was most recently a
coal and oil storage area. But during World War II it was identified
in U.S. Air Force photos as a "hutted encampment"--the site
of barracks housing some of the 15,000 forced workers who, under
SS guards, turned out weapons and vehicles at the plant. The workers
included concentration--camp prisoners, Polish and Russian slave
laborers, and Soviet POWs. A concentration camp stood just to the
north of the site.
Although Autostadt's glass-and-metal architecture speaks of a bright
future, highlighting the symbolism of "brand heritage," Volkswagen's
wartime past inevitably casts darker shadows. The museum displays
"the only Beetle convertible built in 1938." If that's true, then
some visiting Bug buffs will surely identify it as the car Hitler
rode in with Ferry Porsche after groundbreaking ceremonies for the
VW factory.
In
a poll of experts last year Piëch was named auto executive of the
century; Porsche, auto engineer of the century. If for Piëch the
New Beetle matches the achievement of his grandfather, then Autostadt
may be a means of putting to rest the legacy of his father, the
plant's wartime manager. VW is one of the participants in a recently
signed agreement providing about $5 billion in compensation to the
estimated 12 million slave and forced laborers used by German enterprises
during the Nazi years. (Only 2.3 million are estimated to still
be alive.) In 1998 VW established its own $12 million fund to compensate
forced laborers, but survivors are demanding more. One current suit
was filed by Anna Snopczyk, a 79-year-old Polish woman, whose 2-month-old
child died in 1945 of gross neglect in the infamous VW Kinderheim
child-care center, where infants born to forced laborers were systematically
starved to death. (The head of the Kinderheim was hanged in 1947.)
In a bunker inside the factory, the company this spring established
a monument to workers who suffered at the hands of what Wachs calls
"those criminals" who ran the factory in the 1940s. That one of
those criminals was the father of his boss seems to give him no
pause. In 1986 VW's then CEO, Carl Hahn, commissioned Hans Mommsen,
one of Germany's most important historians, to write a history of
the company during the Third Reich. Hahn was head of U.S. operations
in the late 1950s and the man responsible for hiring Doyle Dane
Bernbach to produce their groundbreaking advertising campaign in
the 1960s. Married to an American, Hahn was perhaps more conscious
than his colleagues of the need for VW to come to terms with its
Nazi past.
By the time the book was published in 1996, Piëch had succeeded
Hahn as CEO. And although the book's treatment of his father was
fairly gentle, the younger Piëch was not pleased. According to Mommsen,
Piëch has refused to provide the funds that VW had promised to
translate the book into English. "He's the kind of man who sees
conspiracies," Mommsen says.
The
past is inescapable at the factory itself, where Nazi-era stone
bas-relief images of idealized labor still stand at the entrances.
Although greatly expanded to the north, the original factory is
essentially unchanged. Its most dramatic feature is the power plant,
near Autostadt, and the 21 entrance towers that march along the
canal in a formation as martial as any of Speer's designs for Nuremberg
or Berlin.
Recently a visitor noticed that someone had covered the bust of
Porsche in the town center with a plastic bag and graffiti. Indeed
tensions are palpable there among longtime residents, foreign-born
workers, and former East Germans. And because Wolfsburg was so carefully
planned as a Modernist vision of the new Germany, a city of white
geometries and neat streets, any discordant detail is jarring.
The same is true for Autostadt, which calls on visitors to consider
every detail of the environment and invests so much in making it
symbolic. Little in its design has been left to chance. The park
grounds are meticulously landscaped. An appropriate tree has been
planted near each pavilion: Bentley has an English oak; Skoda, a
Bohemian lime; VW, a "cheerful yet tough and pioneering" birch;
and Lamborghini, a sweet chestnut (the "most Mediterranean" tree
that can survive in Wolfsburg's climate).
A feng shui expert was even consulted. The expert advised planners
to "ground" the theme park by planting oaks and weeping willows
at its entrance: one has powerful roots that connect it to the earth,
the other has light limbs that embrace the air. Autostadt managers
followed the advice but renamed the willow. In German the weeping
willow is called trauerweiden-literally "sorrow willow." But at
Autostadt it will simply be called a willow. "Sorrow," said a VW
publicist, "is not a word we use at Autostadt."
Phil Patton is the author of Dreamland: Travels Inside the Secret
Word of Roswell and Area 51. |